Mr lex lasry, qc, who heads nguyen's melbourne legal team, recently told singapore's high commissioner in canberra that the regime of the mandatory death penalty would have to change. Singapore's mandatory death sentence would be imposed equally on a person who trafficked more than 15 grams of heroin and a person who bombed a government building and killed dozens to place this in context, trafficking a much larger amount of heroin in the united states — 100 to 999 grams — is punishable by five to 40 years in prison. In singapore, the death penalty is mandatory for drug trafficking offenses and president trump loves it he's been telling friends for months that the country's policy to execute drug traffickers is the reason its drug consumption rates are so low. The mandatory death penalty strengthens this deterrent message, teo said during a debate in parliament on a bill amending the anti-drugs law to allow judges some discretion under exceptional circumstances.
The death penalty should be discretionary for the offences where the death sentence is mandatory - murder, drug trafficking, firearms offences and sedition - a position similar to that for the offence of kidnapping there are strong arguments for changing the mandatory nature of capital punishment in singapore. In july 2012, the government of singapore announced in parliament that new laws would be drafted to abolish the mandatory imposition of the death penalty for some categories of drug trafficking offences and homicide offences. On november 2012, the singapore parliament passed important amendments relating to the use of the death penalty in drug trafficking cases what are they and.
Singapore's court of appeal has rejected arguments that the mandatory death penalty is unconstitutional on the basis that it bears a rational relation to the social objective of reducing crime and deterring would-be offenders. Singapore has a partly deserved reputation for sterile predictability that has earned it descriptions like william gibson's disneyland with the death penalty or the world's only shopping mall with a seat in the united nations. Philip alston, the un special rapporteur on extrajudicial executions at the time said in reference to a 2005 drug case in singapore that having a mandatory death penalty violates international.
14 roger hood, the death penalty in malaysia: public opinion on the mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking, murder and firearm offences (london: the death penalty project, 2013) at 17 - 18 15 ibid at 11 324% is the average for the trafficking of 5 different kinds of drugs - heroin, cocaine, amphetamine, cannabis and opium. Singapore is proposing changes to its mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking and murder in some cases under the proposed changes, the courts will have discretion in the sentencing of low-level drug couriers who co-operate with police. Mandatory death penalty in murder and drug offences have been made, it is the opinion of the author that the death penalty will continue to be used in singapore in the foreseeable future keywords deathpenalty singaporedeterrence.
Other countries in the asian region that hand out severe penalties (read: death) as a punishment for drug offences include singapore, thailand, indonesia, and the philippines sources: the star online , wiki , amnesty international , nst / featured image: the prohibition post. The idea that harsh drug laws such as the death penalty are effective is one actively promoted by singapore and it is a belief now allegedly being adopted by us president donald trump. Singapore has also changed its laws on the mandatory death sentence for murder, allowing judges in some cases to impose life imprisonment and caning for some categories of the crime. Toc tv takes to singapore's heartlands (toa payoh) to ask older singaporeans their views on the mandatory death penalty help us caption & translate this video.
A vigil for australian drug smuggler nguyen tuong van before his execution in singapore on 2 december 2005 singapore is proposing to change the law to scrap the mandatory death sentence for drug. The total haul was 3962g of heroin, about 26 times the minimum necessary for a mandatory death penalty in singapore ( wikipedia ) shanmugam sam murugesu , arrested in 2003, executed in 2005. In november 2012, the parliament of singapore made amendments to the mandatory death penalty regime before then, the death penalty for drug trafficking was completely mandatory an individual. Singapore imposes a mandatory sentence of death for murder and has done so for more than a century 18 the story does not end there, for surely it must matter how murder is deﬁned in singapore law.
Singapore's high court exercised its discretion today, sentencing gopinathan nair to life imprisonment with caning instead of the death penalty gopinathan was initially convicted of murder under section 300(a) of the penal code in march 2012 the high court then sentenced him to death under the old mandatory death penalty regime. Legal challenges to the manner in which the death penalty is carried out (namely, that hanging is a form of inhuman punishment or treatment) and to the mandatory death penalty for certain drug.
Singapore: cooperate or die: singapore's flawed reforms to the mandatory death penalty 11 october 2017 , index number: act 50/7158/2017 singapore has recorded a significant reduction in its use of the death penalty in recent years, with executions dropping from more than 70 per year in the mid-1990s to single figures in the subsequent decade. Concern about singapore's use of the mandatory death penalty and high executions rates(11) member states of the eu resolved in their 1998 policy paper on the death penalty to work towards universal abolition of the death penalty. Most executions were for drug offenses while some were for murder and firearms offenses, all of which carry mandatory death sentences in singapore, the report said.